May 172010
 
Apple logo

The hearts of trendy technology fanboys the world ’round have been aflutter over the Apple versus Adobe showdown. All this agitation on the intellectual sea has produced some foam, as agitation will, but I worry when emotions run high and hyperbole runs rampant. A private technology mailing list to which I am privy began dissecting Kevin Lynch’s interview with Brady Forrest at Web 2.0 Expo SF. One gentleman, targeting Mr Lynch’s dark depiction of “walled gardens” (read: the iPad), went so far as to call Mr Lynch an “evil, evil man” for his demands that Apple open its precious platform to Adobe’s products.

Kevin Lynch a twice-evil man, is that not a tick harsh? An unabashed puller of the corporate line, certainly…though as the CTO, he helps write the corporate line. A egotistical geek, sure…again, CTO. Evil? The legal-but-immoral thoughts Steve Jobs wakes up with on a given Tuesday would make Mr Lynch curl up in a ball and beg for his mother, yet still I would hesitate to call Mr Jobs evil. (What is Steve, then? It rhymes with brass soul.)

To consumers, Apple sells delicious little bundles of hardware and software: iPhones, iPods, iPads. Apple also sells, to developers, access to that army of captive consumers, taking its famous 30% cut on App Store purchases. Apple created a platform and is her gatekeeper, censoring content and now dictating development methods. Do we as a society want Apple, or any corporation, to be the lone censor for a widespread and important consumer platform? I submit that society does not. The printing press manufacturer may not censor the daily newspaper. The descendants of Johannes Gutenberg may not challenge J. K. Rowling, no matter how derivative her imagination or childish her writing.

Our entire body of work here at Lab49 depends on tools and platforms built by others, and specifically, much of my own craft involves running Adobe tools on Apple platforms (excepting when bank clients force me onto Secure Build Windows, itself an oxymoron if ever there were one). On one hand I want Apple and Adobe to kiss, make up, and get the band back together for an overpriced reunion tour. On the other hand I enjoy watching two promoters of closed systems accuse each other of promoting closed systems. Hypocrisy may be a scoundrel’s refuge, but it is my entertainment.